Season timeline WARDOGSSeason 03
A soldier in the rain

// Season 03 · the studio

Bulkhead’s
side

What Joe Brammer and the team say on each argument, how they answer criticism across X, Reddit, YouTube and Steam, and how players took it.

// Staff

Who's talking

Joe Brammer

@Brammflakes on X, u/brammflakes on Reddit, CEO on video and Steam

376posts and statements
68%replies to players
8.2%combative or mocking
“I accept not being everyone’s cup of tea, but I think access to the dev team is worth that.”source 1

L0SSY (Brian McCrann)

@L0SSY on X, u/Lossy_ on Reddit

163posts and statements
97%replies to players
2.5%combative or mocking
“100% CRAZY short-notice today. Unavoidable I'm afraid, it was a mandatory maintenance window that we had very little time to prepare for.”source 2

Howard Philpott

@HowardPhilpott on X, community and UX

66posts and statements
85%replies to players
1.5%combative or mocking
“We are looking to place restrictions on team switching but playing with friends is massively important”source 3

Mark Tadros

technical designer; appears on the Hotzone podcast and devlogs only, no X account in this record

28posts and statements
0%replies to players
0%combative or mocking
“with the little bit minigun by buffing it slightly, we didn't change the level. And I will admit that was probably a mistake.”source 4

Official Bulkhead accounts

@WARDOGS and @BULKHEAD on X, and the @BULKHEAD. YouTube channel

78posts and statements
59%replies to players
0%combative or mocking
“We made it clear that known cash & xp exploit abuse will no longer be tolerated.”source 5

Other Bulkhead voices

Tim (creative director), Pete (lead designer), unattributed Hotzone panel members, Steam announcement and devlog narration

196posts and statements
0%replies to players
1%combative or mocking
“those things were meant to persist across all seasons. That's persistent character.”source 6

// Argument by argument

Their line versus where players landed

Each row puts Bulkhead's public position right next to the pooled share of players on the positive side of that argument.

// Replies to players

When they answered back

The standout staff replies to player criticism, showing the tone of what they said and a sample of player replies underneath.

  1. L0SSY (u/Lossy_)19 Nov · RedditConciliatoryServers & kicks
    “But yes, 100% CRAZY short-notice today. Unavoidable I'm afraid, it was a mandatory maintenance window that we had very little time to prepare for.”source 2

    Responding to: Thread complaining that a server maintenance window was announced on Discord two minutes before it startedsource 30

    46% supportive · 23% critical of 35 replies sampled. Well received - the top-scoring staff comment of the week at 132, and the only Season 3 exchange sampled where supportive comments outnumber critical ones two to one.

  2. Joe Brammer (CEO), Mark Tadros, Tim19 Nov · YouTubeConciliatoryThe unlock grind
    “we're like yes we fixed the cheaters. [ __ ] those guys. We've done it. We're the best dev team. How did this weekend go? Everyone hates us.”source 31

    Responding to: EclipseFPS's video calling the studio out of touch, which Bulkhead answered by inviting him onto its own podcast for 104 minutessource 32

    58% supportive · 17% critical of 24 replies sampled. The best-received thing Bulkhead did in the window: 58% of sampled posts were supportive, repeatedly on the grounds that few studios host their loudest critic.

  3. @BULKHEAD (YouTube channel)19 Nov · YouTubeConciliatoryHow Bulkhead talks to players
    “We were on the fence about releasing this video but we do think this style of open communication is better for players.”source 33

    Responding to: EclipseFPS's video calling Bulkhead out of touch, and the argument that followed about whether the studio should keep talking at allsource 32

    65% supportive · 8% critical of 40 replies sampled. The warmest reception of anything in the record: 65% of the sampled replies back the format, 8% are against, and several ask the team to get some sleep rather than stop.

  4. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes)17 Nov · XConciliatoryHow Bulkhead talks to players
    “Just want to add, few comments of people discussing Eclipse being a “whiner”.. I don’t think that’s the case. As I said on stream, we are very lucky to have someone this passionate”source 34

    Responding to: Supporters of the studio calling EclipseFPS a whiner after Brammer's stream reactionsource 35

    36% supportive · 29% critical of 75 replies sampled. The first staff line in the fortnight with more support than criticism in its sample (36% to 29%), and the point at which the argument started to cool.

  5. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes)16 Nov · XConciliatoryHow Bulkhead talks to players
    “Lots of valid points, some of the delivery gets under my skin for sure, that’s just the way I am. Worth a watch”source 36

    Responding to: EclipseFPS's hour-long video calling Bulkhead out of touch over Season 3 progression, tanks and the Gold Marketsource 32

    27% supportive · 70% critical of 30 replies sampled. The turn was noticed but not forgiven: 70% of the sampled thread stayed critical, much of it about his “go make your own game studio” line on stream the same night.

  6. Joe Brammer (u/brammflakes)16 Nov · RedditConciliatoryHow Bulkhead talks to players
    “Ok, all fair feedback. I’ll watch it on stream tonight.”source 37

    Responding to: Thread saying it is arrogant to shrug off EclipseFPS's video after watching ten minutes of itsource 38

    0% supportive · 90% critical of 30 replies sampled. The comment scored 115 but the thread around it did not move - 90% of the sampled tail was still critical.

  7. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes)15 Nov · XDefensiveHow Bulkhead talks to players
    “Nah, the first 10 minutes was this guy saying how he’s played for hours and we don’t and that he knows everything.”source 39

    Responding to: Player asking whether Brammer would answer EclipseFPS's critique the way he had answered other videossource 40

    6% supportive · 91% critical of 35 replies sampled. The worst-received staff line measured here: 91% of the sampled thread was critical, the dominant complaint being that he had judged an hour-long video on ten minutes.

  8. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes)14 Nov · XConciliatoryReport-driven bans
    “We have disabled the banning feature.”source 14

    Responding to: Thread about a streamer auto-banned by mass reports after a 151-kill minigun Little Bird gamesource 41

    9% supportive · 14% critical of 35 replies sampled. The reversal itself was barely argued with; 77% of the sampled thread was neutral, the rest split between relief and complaints about the bans already issued.

  9. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes)14 Nov · XCombativeXP-farm bans
    “Exploit abuse early season or gold farming at some point. Be grateful it’s 3 days. Now, deny it.”source 42

    Responding to: Player asking Bulkhead to lift a wave of three-day bans and say what they were forsource 43

    38% supportive · 46% critical of 24 replies sampled. Split against him: 46% of the sampled ban-wave posts were critical and 38% supportive, with several pointing out he had answered an appeal with a dare.

  10. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes)14 Nov · XCombativeXP-farm bans
    “Hey Blaine, Between Oct 30 and Nov 1, your account earned about 2.6 million cash by exploiting the reward system on farm servers: • Oct 30: 495k (88% of that day’s earnings) • Oct 31: 351k (72%) • Nov 1: 1.76M (88%), with 11 kills across 6 matches Your matches show abnormal spotting rewards, mass revives and repeated kills on the same players. This was exploit abuse and farming. The ban is temporary and ends Nov 16. Any further exploiting will lead to a permanent ban. Nothing to do with your helicopter or what you were doing at that moment.”source 44

    Responding to: Blaine Smith posting “I don't know why I was banned, I was just flying in my helicopter.... 😆” while quoting someone else's tweet with the name cropped outsource 45

    32% supportive · 22% critical of 40 replies sampled. Joe published the exploit earnings of the banned account, which was not Blaine's: Blaine replied “That's not me mate. It was a Tweet. I just chopped the persons name out so there was no dogpiling” and Joe confirmed “isn’t them :) just someone they quoted”. r/WarDogs still scored the receipt 3,795, and a parody reply posting Joe's own playtime back at him took 21,162 likes.

  11. Howard Philpott (@HowardPhilpott)14 Nov · XDefensiveHow Bulkhead talks to players
    “Just want to be clear... we did not 'take advice' from them on any changes for S3. We had a discord call to talk wardogs and debate claims and disagreed on alot... it was fun!”source 46

    Responding to: Creator arguing that streamers kill games because developers change them on streamers' criticismsource 47

    25% supportive · 35% critical of 48 replies sampled. More against than for (35% to 25%), and his follow-up reply - “the fuck you talking about lmao” - drew its own round of complaints about staff tone.

  12. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes)13 Nov · XDefensiveThe hammer grind
    “Yeh it’s been observed, honestly I think the design team generally did a really good job this season, but the early stuff is a bit hard with the obvious one or two issues. I don’t think the LB is a problem, it’s the Hammer.”source 10

    Responding to: Creator BigfryTV reporting that the tier-3 hammer at level 14 gates every useful FOB buildable, so teams spam-build to grind supportsource 48

    14% supportive · 63% critical of 35 replies sampled. Rejected: r/WarDogs made the message its own 2,563-score thread and 63% of sampled comments were against it, mostly arguing the Little Bird and the hammer are both problems.

  13. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes)13 Nov · XDefensiveHow Bulkhead talks to players
    “Just going to add, some of the hyperbolic and vitriolic language used particularly on Reddit towards the design team is not ok.. call me a fat square headed mong all you like- but those guys have put in A LOT of hours and read everything people say because that’s their job.”source 49

    Responding to: Sustained r/WarDogs abuse of the design team over the Season 3 hammer and Little Bird changessource 50

    0% supportive · 70% critical of 30 replies sampled. Not one sampled comment in the matching Reddit thread backed the studio; 70% were critical, arguing the balance complaint was being reframed as a civility problem.

  14. Joe Brammer (u/brammflakes)13 Nov · RedditDefensiveHow Bulkhead talks to players
    “But let's keep the attacks focused on me, and not the design team or the dev team. They're just doing their job and working hard.”source 51

    Responding to: Top comment in the thread implying Bulkhead is looking for a way out of early access rather than finishing the gamesource 52

    17% supportive · 74% critical of 35 replies sampled. The thread below the top comments stayed hostile - 74% critical against 17% supportive - though the comment itself held a positive score of 51.

  15. Joe Brammer (u/brammflakes)7 Nov · RedditDefensiveThe review-score debate
    “Just write a bad review.. we don’t care. Just be honest about your views of the game. It’s not us that made these rules. Don’t hate the player hate the game.”source 29

    Responding to: Thread complaining that Bulkhead's repeated asks for Steam reviews are manipulativesource 53

    67% supportive · 20% critical of 30 replies sampled. The most positively received staff line in the sample - two thirds of sampled comments back the studio, reading it as the opposite of review begging.

  16. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes)7 Nov · XCombativeGraphics-setting bans
    “Word of warning, we have not been able to detect if you’re abusing potato mode or Nvidia inspector (or any graphics changes)… Until now. Season 3 we will be detecting these changes and banning for them, I recommend a fresh install if you’d like a second chance. Fair warning.”source 24

    Responding to: Representative, not the direct parent: the running argument that Bulkhead bans for graphics settings while real cheaters stay insource 54

    29% supportive · 42% critical of 38 replies sampled. Split and loud: 42% of the sampled replies attacked the policy, 29% backed it, and the post drew 683 replies against 4,258 likes - the widest-read staff post of the fortnight.

  17. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes)7 Nov · XCombativeGraphics-setting bans
    “So we just tampered with Unreal Engine? Who tampered with Quake? 🤔 Not the same thing. Down for modding, big time… loads of people have been doing awesome things. Changing a file so you don’t have smoke? Yeh that’s not modding mate.. cmon don’t pretend this is a villain arc.”source 55

    Responding to: Player telling Brammer that WARDOGS itself descends from people tampering with Arma's game filessource 56

    27% supportive · 40% critical of 30 replies sampled. Critical on balance (40% against, 27% for) though the line itself was popular, taking 1,957 likes on only 70 replies.

  18. Joe Brammer (u/brammflakes)24 Oct · RedditConciliatoryHow Bulkhead talks to players
    “Just for clarity, it's our fault. Nobody elses.”source 57

    Responding to: Hotzone Ep1 thread arguing the Season 2 wipe and progression mess was caused by the studio chasing player feedbacksource 58

    27% supportive · 47% critical of 30 replies sampled. The apology itself was accepted by some, but the surrounding thread stayed critical - roughly twice as many sampled comments attacked the decision as backed it.

  19. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes)22 Oct · XConciliatoryPing caps & region lock
    “Appreciate this post. Also appreciate that we’re harming a % of players to protect the larger. We will find a solution, this issue is bigger than wardogs though..”source 59

    Responding to: Open letter from a Korean WARDOGS creator saying the Asian servers and ping limits have cut his region out of the gamesource 60

    20% supportive · 37% critical of 30 replies sampled. Mixed on Reddit, where the region-lock announcement thread ran clearly negative; the X reply itself drew 591 likes and little argument.

  20. Joe Brammer (u/brammflakes)21 Oct · RedditExplanatoryCheaters in matches
    “I can confirm our vision is to bring a public facing “trust score” next year where players can increase their score based on things like secure boot, TPM, and maybe PlaysafeID”source 61

    Responding to: Thread asking Bulkhead to require Secure Boot to keep cheats outsource 62

    20% supportive · 17% critical of 30 replies sampled. Mostly technical argument rather than reaction to Joe; the comment itself scored 92 and the thread debates whether Secure Boot would work at all.

  21. Joe Brammer (u/brammflakes)18 Sep · RedditExplanatoryFOBs & logistics
    “Hey, great write up. I will say that we do have the round trip bonus, just nobody notices. We actually have addressed this for season 2 already”source 21

    Responding to: Long write-up arguing the driver/logistics loop pays too little for the time it takessource 63

    13% supportive · 17% critical of 30 replies sampled. Overwhelmingly well received: the reply is the highest-scoring staff comment in the record at 1,554 and the thread treats it as the studio engaging properly.

// Tone

How the tone's shifted

Every staff post and statement we track, sorted by week and by tone.

Bulkhead staff posts per week by toneStacked bars, one per week from 10 Sep to 19 Nov, splitting each week's staff posts into conciliatory, explanatory, defensive, combative and mocking.10 Sep: 10 conciliatory10 Sep: 36 explanatory10 Sep: 1 defensive10 Sep17 Sep: 3 conciliatory17 Sep: 30 explanatory17 Sep: 5 defensive17 Sep: 2 combative17 Sep: 4 mocking17 Sep24 Sep: 9 conciliatory24 Sep: 38 explanatory24 Sep: 13 defensive24 Sep: 2 combative24 Sep: 2 mocking24 Sep1 Oct: 8 conciliatory1 Oct: 21 explanatory1 Oct: 3 defensive1 Oct: 1 mocking1 Oct8 Oct: 18 conciliatory8 Oct: 120 explanatory8 Oct: 10 defensive8 Oct: 4 combative8 Oct15 Oct: 6 conciliatory15 Oct: 31 explanatory15 Oct: 10 defensive15 Oct: 1 combative15 Oct22 Oct: 24 conciliatory22 Oct: 58 explanatory22 Oct: 8 defensive22 Oct: 1 combative22 Oct29 Oct: 2 conciliatory29 Oct: 35 explanatory29 Oct: 3 defensive29 Oct: 1 combative29 Oct: 2 mocking29 Oct5 Nov: 25 conciliatory5 Nov: 152 explanatory5 Nov: 23 defensive5 Nov: 9 combative5 Nov: 1 mocking5 Nov12 Nov: 24 conciliatory12 Nov: 62 explanatory12 Nov: 14 defensive12 Nov: 7 combative12 Nov: 1 mocking12 Nov19 Nov: 13 conciliatory19 Nov: 33 explanatory19 Nov: 21 defensive19 Nov2100

ConciliatoryExplanatoryDefensiveCombativeMocking

Sources on this page

  1. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes), 2026-11-15X post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  2. L0SSY (u/Lossy_), 2026-11-19Reddit thread · reddit.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩1 ↩2
  3. Howard Philpott (@HowardPhilpott), 2026-11-02X post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  4. Mark Tadros (technical designer), 2026-11-19Video · youtube.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  5. @WARDOGS, 2026-10-07X post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩1 ↩2
  6. Pete (lead designer), 2026-10-24Video · youtube.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  7. Tim (creative director), YouTube, 2026-11-19Video · youtube.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  8. @WARDOGS, X, 2026-09-10X post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  9. Bulkhead (Steam post, Season 02 Preview), Steam, 2026-10-09Official post · steamstore-a.akamaihd.net · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  10. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes), X, 2026-11-13X post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩1 ↩2
  11. Bulkhead (Steam post, Season 02 Patch Notes), Steam, 2026-10-14Official post · steamstore-a.akamaihd.net · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  12. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes), X, 2026-10-19X post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  13. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes), X, 2026-11-08X post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  14. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes), X, 2026-11-14X post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩1 ↩2
  15. Bulkhead (Road to S3 narrators), YouTube, 2026-11-06Video · youtube.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  16. Joe Brammer (CEO), YouTube, 2026-11-19Video · youtube.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  17. Mark Tadros (technical designer), YouTube, 2026-11-19Video · youtube.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  18. Bulkhead (Steam post, Minor Balance Patch 0.31), Steam, 2026-11-19Official post · store.steampowered.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  19. Joe Brammer (CEO), YouTube, 2026-10-09Video · youtube.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  20. Bulkhead (Steam post, Season 03 Patch Notes), Steam, 2026-11-11Official post · store.steampowered.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩1 ↩2
  21. Joe Brammer (u/brammflakes), Reddit, 2026-09-18Reddit thread · reddit.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩1 ↩2
  22. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes), X, 2026-10-13X post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  23. Joe Brammer (CEO), YouTube, 2026-10-24Video · youtube.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  24. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes), X, 2026-11-07X post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩1 ↩2
  25. Bulkhead (Hotzone Ep2 panel, unattributed), YouTube, 2026-11-10Video · youtube.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  26. Bulkhead (Hotzone Ep1 panel, unattributed), YouTube, 2026-10-24Video · youtube.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  27. Bulkhead (Road to S3 narrators), YouTube, 2026-11-06Video · youtube.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  28. Bulkhead (Road to S3 narrators), YouTube, 2026-11-06Video · youtube.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  29. Joe Brammer (u/brammflakes), Reddit, 2026-11-07Reddit thread · reddit.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩1 ↩2
  30. The post Bulkhead replied toReddit thread · reddit.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  31. Joe Brammer (CEO), Mark Tadros, Tim, YouTube, 2026-11-19Video · youtube.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  32. The post Bulkhead replied toVideo · youtube.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩1 ↩2 ↩3
  33. @BULKHEAD (YouTube channel), YouTube, 2026-11-19Video · youtube.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  34. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes), X, 2026-11-17X post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  35. The post Bulkhead replied toReddit thread · reddit.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  36. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes), X, 2026-11-16X post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  37. Joe Brammer (u/brammflakes), Reddit, 2026-11-16Reddit thread · reddit.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  38. The post Bulkhead replied toReddit thread · reddit.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  39. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes), X, 2026-11-15X post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  40. The post Bulkhead replied toX post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  41. The post Bulkhead replied toReddit thread · reddit.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  42. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes), X, 2026-11-14X post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  43. The post Bulkhead replied toX post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  44. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes), X, 2026-11-14X post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  45. The post Bulkhead replied toX post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  46. Howard Philpott (@HowardPhilpott), X, 2026-11-14X post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  47. The post Bulkhead replied toX post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  48. The post Bulkhead replied toX post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  49. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes), X, 2026-11-13X post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  50. The post Bulkhead replied toReddit thread · reddit.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  51. Joe Brammer (u/brammflakes), Reddit, 2026-11-13Reddit thread · reddit.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  52. The post Bulkhead replied toReddit thread · reddit.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  53. The post Bulkhead replied toReddit thread · reddit.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  54. The post Bulkhead replied toX post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  55. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes), X, 2026-11-07X post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  56. The post Bulkhead replied toX post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  57. Joe Brammer (u/brammflakes), Reddit, 2026-10-24Reddit thread · reddit.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  58. The post Bulkhead replied toReddit thread · reddit.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  59. Joe Brammer (@Brammflakes), X, 2026-10-22X post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  60. The post Bulkhead replied toX post · x.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  61. Joe Brammer (u/brammflakes), Reddit, 2026-10-21Reddit thread · reddit.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  62. The post Bulkhead replied toReddit thread · reddit.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩
  63. The post Bulkhead replied toReddit thread · reddit.com · accessed 13 Nov 2026↩